Nov 12 2009
School Library Ditches Books
I recently heard on NPR that the school library at Cushing Academy, Ashburnham, MA has completely done away with books in favor of digital texts. From the NPR story:
Dean of Academics Suzie Carlisle says school officials had noticed the trend. She says surveys they conducted showed students weren’t turning to printed materials for research. Instead, they were immediately going online.
The kids of Lunchtime Leader Podcast recently asked me a question about this trend. If I would have known about the Cushing Academy story I could have looked like I was really on top of this, but I just sort of hemmed & hawed my way through it. What I had completely forgotten about was that I have previously taken a stand on this issue.
Too often, students rush headlong into cyberspace without considering what wealth of information they might be missing in printed form. The truth of the matter is the vast majority of the world’s knowledge is still not publicly available in digital form. This notion was driven home to me last spring as I slogged my way through the papers of the Eisenhower Library for a History of American Education research assignment on the National Defense Education Act. There’s simply no way the information I found could be discovered anywhere online. Maybe I’m not tech-savvy enough, but I challenge you to find the full text of the NDEA law online somewhere… I couldn’t. I found it easily in a book.
A couple of years ago, I taught a Humanities through the Arts course, and a major research project I assigned was called the “Dead Artist’s Project”. Students were to study up and prepare a research presentation on an artist of any artform (literature, drama, music, art, etc.) but the catch was it had to be an artist who died before the researcher was born. (Originally the only requirement was the artist be dead, but I kept getting Michael Jackson, Heath Ledger and Anna Nichole type stories.) It was fascinating, and forced them to consider the creative genius of a generation who came before they were alive. In addition, I required that at least two print sources be cited as references.
We spent time in the library, browsing the stacks, and seeing what we could discover. I can’t tell you how many times I serendipitously discovered related reading materials using this method and you simply can’t have a similar experience in a database-the search methodology is so different.
I think it’s a mistake that libraries are keen to yank all of their printed materials. Am I just getting old?





























